If it wasn’t clear before, the gloves are officially off in the relationship between California Assembly Speaker Fabian Nunez (D-Los Angeles) and the California Nurses Association. Today’s Sacramento Bee has CNA openly calling for Nunez (sorry, I don’t know how to get my blog to bring the requisite tilde to Nunez’s name) to recuse himself from the health care debate due to his wife’s lucrative position with the hospital industry.
The same article has Nunez spokesman Steve Maviglio firing back calling the nurses “radical and out of touch.”
In my experience this kind of open declaration of war between a progressive union and a Democratic leader of the legislature is unprecedented in recent California politics. It simply isn’t done.
And, yes, I am known as the Miss Manners of the California Legislature. Everyone knows how much I respect the etiquette of the place.
But whether it is or isn’t done, it has been. The CNA leadership clearly has decided that they are not going to let Fabian Nunez get in the way of their goal of achieving single payer health care in California.
I find this open push for what Californians really need refreshing, if risky politically. The goals of the deal that Nunez and Schwarzenegger are negotiating towards reveal that it is they, rather than the C.N.A., who are out of touch with the people of California who want universal health care, real systemic change, not whatever the meager parameters of the politically possible may bring.
Flagging Nunez’ supposed conflict of interest is just a convenient way to attempt to blow up this deal. I remember when Paul Koretz was first sitting on the Assembly health committee he had a policy of “recusing” himself from voting on every health care bill that involved Kaiser Permanente because his wife worked for Kaiser. Since virtually every bill was opposed by Kaiser, the net result of Koretz’ conflict resolution was to provide a convenient permanent abstention for Kaiser so that the proponents of these measures had to work to replace his vote. It was lunacy.
I don’t think the Speaker of the Assembly can reasonably be asked to recuse himself from attempting to solve one of the most important crises of the state. I do, however, think he can be asked to get serious, stop playing the hospitals’ game, and put the people of California first.